Reasons Why Kominfo Blocks Whatsapp, IG and Google

Rancakmedia.com – The reason behind why Kominfo blocks WhatsApp, IG, Google etc. Please refer to the information to find out the details in the article we have made, enjoy reading.

Recently there has been a lot of controversy regarding the speech of the Ministry of Communication and Informatics (Kominfo) which commemorated the banning of many internet networks.

Kominfo claims it will ban WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook, Google and other internet networks in the coming days. What is the purpose of WhatsApp warnings and the like in the Kominfo debate?

Kominfo plans to block WhatsApp

On June 22, 2022, Kominfo's conversation to limit WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook, or Google, among other services, began. PSE Indonesia (Electronic System Manager) has a pending appeal regarding the registration deadline.

WhatsApp Blocking Plan, Instagram, Facebook Etc

On June 22, Dedy Permadi, Communication and Informatics Spokesperson, asked the person in charge of Indonesia's electronic system to register with the Kominfo system no later than July 20, 2022.

Dedy said at the Central Jakarta Kominfo Building on June 22: "The deadline for Scope Private PSE registration using the online single submission-risk based approach (OSS-RBA) system is July 20, 2022."

Dedy gave an example of the Circular of the Minister of Communication and Information Number 3 of 2022 which stated that private electronic system operators must have been registered no later than June 14, 2022, to be able to do business.

The Kominfo system has the potential to limit access to the PSE Platform or Personal Scope site after July 20, 2022, if the platform or site has not been registered.

Banning services from a Private Scope PSE is based on at least two rules. First, Government Regulation 71 of 2019 (PP 71/2019) concerning the Use of Electronic Systems and Transactions.

Second, Regulation of the Minister of Communication and Informatics Number 5 of 2020 concerning Private Electronic System Operators (Menkominfo 5/2020). Here's a look at the PSE policy for more information.

By definition, a PSE is a private person, government agency, or business that offers, manages, or operates electronic systems for its customers.

PP 71/2019 mandates registration of all PSEs, public and private, with Kominfo. The aim is to coordinate the use of technology in Indonesia.

In the case of registration of Private PSE, the procedures are regulated in the Regulation of the Minister of Communication and Informatics 5/2020. In accordance with this regulation, PSE Private Scope registration is carried out using the Online Single Submission (OSS) system.

PSE, such as WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook, and so on, must register to obtain a form of license to operate their electronic system services in Indonesia.

To obtain this permit, PSE Private Scope must submit an application for registration to the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology. This application must include the following information:

Names, IP addresses, descriptions of personal data processed, and so on are general descriptions of the functioning of electronic systems. Also includes security certification and other guarantees of the system.

  1. Obligation to ensure information security in accordance with statutory provisions.
  2. The obligation to protect Personal Data in accordance with statutory provisions.
  3. The obligation to carry out an Electronic System adequacy test in accordance with the provisions of the laws and regulations.

If the Private Scope PSE does not carry out its responsibilities in accordance with this rule, the PSE will be subject to administrative consequences. Administrative penalties include denying them access to their computer systems or banning them completely.

Unregistered PSE

Even though the registration deadline is getting closer, many well-known people from PSE Private Scope have not registered on the PSE Kominfo website.

On the pse.kominfo.go.id portal, Monday (18/7/2022), large PSEs such as Google, Facebook, WhatsApp, Instagram, Netflix, Twitter, Zoom, and YouTube still do not appear as registered PSEs.

By not registering yet, it implies that certain services from these companies may be blocked. It's not clear why the tech business hasn't been listed. To be honest, Kominfo has applied for PSE status since last year.

It was decided that neither of them would talk about the company's failure to register with the PSE. Twitter has just indicated that they are monitoring and assessing the matter.

Google Says It Will Comply With Applicable Rules

A Google official said: "This is something we are aware of and will do in an effort to comply." However, until now, the names of large companies offering search engine services have not been registered on the Kominfo PSE website.

Public Reaction To Whatsapp, IG and Google Block Warning

On the other hand, on the website, you can also find registered companies or PSEs, such as TikTok, Spotify, Linktree, Gojek, Tokopedia, OVO, Blibli, Seeds, Traveloka, Viu, Telegram, Mobile Legends, and others.

Won't Get Blocked Immediately

Minister of Communication and Informatics 5/2020 said, before Kominfo can impose administrative fines or limit services, it must first cooperate with other authorities or ministries.

Dedy also said that after working with other ministries, Kominfo would contact PSEs that had not been registered to find out why they had not been registered.

"If there is not a good enough explanation from the Ministry of Communication and Informatics, we will immediately turn off access according to PM 5/2020 and its amendments," said Dedy.

This communication mechanism implies that unregistered PSE Private Scopes will likely not be automatically blocked after July 20, 2022.

Then, if the Private Scope PSE has been blocked, service access can still be restored or normalized. Previously blocked PSEs now have to follow Indonesian law to normalize.

This is the Kominfo explanation regarding the ban on WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook, or Google which will take effect from 20 July. Hope it is useful.

Pros Cons Kominfo Warning Block WhatsApp

the warning of the Ministry of Communication and Informatics (Kominfo) to ban Google from popular social media platforms such as Facebook, WhatsApp, Instagram, and Twitter had both positive and negative consequences.

This is because some of these online service providers have not been registered as GCAs or Private GCAs (Private Electronic System Operators).

Urgent PSE Regulations for Indonesia's Digital Sovereignty

The PSE law is very important for Indonesia's digital sovereignty. Step Kominfo received the support of a cybersecurity expert, Alfons Tanujaya.

Urgent PSE Regulations for Indonesia's Digital Sovereignty

For him, the succession of technology giants is marked as being blocked because they are not registered, so PSE must submit to Indonesia's digital sovereignty. Alfons also said that, even though this rule has been in effect since 2000, many social media sites on the list have not registered with PSE.

"The mandatory PSE list is a matter of Indonesia's digital sovereignty. In fact, the question is why it has only been implemented now, the rules have existed since 2000," said Alfons, Monday (18/7/2022) in his statement.

Alfons also gave an example of the efforts made by the European Union government to be tough on PSE.

For this reason, “This is due to their strict, indiscriminate, consistent, professional enforcement of rules, supported by all EU countries and a benchmark for the world,” said Alfons.

As a guarantee, Alfons asked the government to take firm action if PSE still interfered. Alfons also asked the government to notify people if any social media sites will be blocked in the future.

The PSE rules are considered to contain rubber articles

Contrary to Alfons, Teguh Aprianto, founder of Ethical Hacker Indonesia, who is a fellow cyber specialist, feels that the Kominfo law includes several rubber provisions.

Government Regulation Number 71 of 2019 and Ministerial Regulation Number 10 of 2021 concerning Amendments to Ministerial Regulation Number 5 of 2020 (Permenkominfo 5/2020) concerning the Minister of Communication and Informatics governing Private Electronic System Operators (PSE).

Through his statement on Twitter, Teguh highlighted that the items "disturbing the public" and "disturbing public order" in Article 9 Paragraphs 3 and 4 are rubber articles because at any time someone's upload can be deleted without his knowledge because it contains both of these things. point.

“Later on it can be used to 'turn off' criticism even though it is conveyed peacefully. What's the basis? All they have to do is 'disturb public order'," Teguh said.

A further worry for Teguh is that the PP regulations can be used to pressure anyone who voices his disapproval of the government.

“What is the guarantee that this will not be misused to limit or end the movements of those who are against the government? There isn't one right?," continued Teguh.

Through these difficulties, Teguh demanded that PSE registration for the private sector be stopped. The following google and meta response about block warning PSE Kominfo that you might not know about.

Public Reaction To Whatsapp, IG and Google Block Warning

Not only technical professionals, but also ordinary people respond to criticism of Kominfo's actions. Several other Twitter users expressed Teguh's concerns in the comments section of the tweet. One netizen commented:

Public Reaction To Whatsapp, IG and Google Block Warning

"It turns out that PSE Kominfo is actually dangerous,"

On a different platform, one netizen suddenly joked that this rule forces people to return to communicating the way they used to.

“Wow, this is cool, I can switch to SMS. If you have texted at least 3 people, you can get free SMS to all operators. Nostalgia,” wrote one user on the internet.

Not only that, there are also netizens who highlight the PSE registration site provided by Kominfo. The reason is, netizens glanced at the site because it could not be reached on Sunday (17/7/2022).

"Requires registration, uses a warning to block, but the registration page is blank. Kominfo is increasingly becoming the laughing stock of IT worldwide. Embarrassing,"

Conclusion

The Indonesian Ministry of Communication and Information (Kominfo) warned that it would ban many internet networks. WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook, Google and other social media platforms were commemorated with a Denial of Service (DDoS) attack by Kominfo on 22 June 2022.

This is information about the reasons why the Ministry of Communication and Information blocked WhatsApp, IG, and also Google. Hopefully the above article can be uplifting and helpful for all of you.

Back to top button
RANCAK MEDIA